A dark lipstick can look beautiful in the tube and feel like far too much once it’s on your face. Especially when you’re wearing a sweatshirt and getting ready to pick up groceries.
Try tapping it on instead. A little berry pressed into the lips looks quite different from a full, carefully outlined coat. You still get the color, but it feels easier to wear with whatever else you have going on that day.
That’s the approach behind these seven fall makeup looks. Brown eyeshadow you can soften, blush that doesn’t need a contour routine underneath it, a red lip that works with your regular makeup. A few suggestions for getting more use out of the things already in your drawer, too.
I’d begin with the lipstick or shadow you like but never quite know when to wear. It might only need a different application.
Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. Loom & Lush may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Product mentions are shopping suggestions, not personal wear-test reviews.
Have a Look Through Your Makeup Before Buying Anything For Fall makeup looks
You may already have the brown, rose, or plum you’re looking for. Check the less-used end of your palettes and the lipsticks tucked behind your everyday one.
Set out a neutral shadow, a pencil, mascara, blush, and a couple of lip colors. That’s enough to try several of the combinations below. You can decide whether anything is missing after you’ve had a go.
Pay attention to finish as well as color. A sparkling brown gives you a different eye from a matte brown; a glossy berry won’t look like a blotted matte lipstick. Choose the effect you want before assuming you need a different shade.
And keep the cool colors if those are what you enjoy wearing. Taupe, cranberry, plum, and mauve have just as much room here as cinnamon and copper.
If you’re sorting through other parts of your routine, our realistic September reset has more ideas for making use of what you own.
1. Soft Espresso Eyes
A soft brown eye is a good next step when mascara feels a little too plain but a black smoky eye feels like a lot. You can wear it with a rose lipstick, a sheer gloss, or just balm.
The brown doesn’t have to be particularly dark. Look for enough contrast against your eyelid to give some definition. Cocoa might do that for you; someone else may need a richer chocolate.
Start close to the lashes
Press a small amount of shadow onto the lid near the upper lash line. Blend the upper edge with a clean, soft brush, using what’s already there before picking up more.
Then open your eyes and look straight ahead. This is the useful bit. The placement that looks right with your eyes closed may barely show once they’re open, so check as you go.
For more depth, add a darker brown along the outer part of the upper lashes. Leave the lower lash line clear for now and add mascara. You might find that’s enough.
If your collection is missing neutral shades, the e.l.f. Perfect 10 Eyeshadow Palette in Need It Nude is an option to consider. An existing palette with a brown you like will do the job, too.
When brown looks orange
Try a cooler cocoa or a brown with a gray undertone. Going lighter isn’t always the answer: pale taupe can look ashy on some complexions. A deeper cool brown may give you better definition without that orange cast.
Keep your usual base with this. There’s no need to change your foundation just because you’ve changed your eyeshadow.
2. A Blurred Berry Lip
This is a lovely way to use a lipstick that only comes out for special occasions. Worn lightly, the same shade can look much more relaxed.
Apply balm first if you need it, then blot away any slippery excess. With a clean fingertip or lip brush, tap a little lipstick toward the center of the lips and work outward. Stay within your natural lip line, softening the color as you approach the edge.
Have a look before adding another layer. Deep lipstick builds quickly, and you may already have the sheer effect you wanted.
Choose a finish you’ll enjoy wearing
The Revlon Super Lustrous The Luscious Mattes Lipstick in Black Cherry is a deeper option. The linked version is matte, so keep that in mind if you prefer a creamier-looking or glossy lip.
You can try the same application with another lipstick you already find comfortable. Some formulas spread more evenly in a thin layer than others; if yours keeps going patchy, it may simply work better at fuller coverage.
Pair the lip with mascara and your usual brows. A little rose blush can help, especially if the berry looks quite stark against your base. You don’t need to find an exact matching blush.
One practical detail: a stain-like appearance doesn’t make regular lipstick transfer-proof. Bring it along if you’ll want to touch up after lunch.
3. Rosy Cheeks With Simple Eyes
For days when you don’t want to spend time on eye makeup, give the cheeks a little more attention. Rose blush, mascara, and a familiar lip color make a pretty combination with a gray sweater or a plain white shirt.
Placement changes the effect quite a bit. Start nearer the center of the cheeks for a rounded flush, or a little higher and farther out along the cheekbones for a more lifted look.
Neither needs a heavy first layer. Apply a little, blend, and step back from the mirror to see both cheeks together. It’s surprisingly easy to lose track of the amount when you’re concentrating on one small area.
Decide how much shine you want
A luminous blush adds reflection as well as color. If your base is already dewy, you might prefer a matte blush and keep the shine where it is.
The Milani Baked Blush in Sparkling Rosé is one option for a luminous finish. Choose based on how the shade and finish suit you, rather than trying to replace a blush that’s already working.
For deeper skin, a rich rose, berry, plum, or red-brown may give a clearer flush than several layers of a pale pink. If the color barely shows or looks chalky, more blending may not solve it; try a shade with greater depth.
And the little sweep of blush over the nose? Entirely optional. If you’ve just covered redness there, you can leave that work alone.
4. A Jewel-Toned Eye, Starting Small
Emerald eyeshadow sounds ambitious until you use it as a narrow line beside your lashes. You can see the green up close, but it doesn’t have to take over your face.
That’s where I’d start with a color you haven’t worn before. Press an eye-safe plum, emerald, or sapphire shadow along the upper lash line using a small brush. Add mascara and check the result from a normal distance.
Plum is an easy move from brown. Emerald looks especially pretty with cream or navy clothing. Sapphire gives a darker eye a visible blue tone without requiring a whole palette of colors.
Want the color across your lid?
Use a light layer of the same shadow, then soften the outer edge with a clean brush. Leave yourself room to add more near the lashes rather than starting with the darkest possible application.
If the powder tends to fall onto your cheeks, do your eyes before foundation or concealer. Cleaning up loose color is easier when there’s no finished base underneath.
For the first try, wear a lip color you know you like. It helps to have something familiar on your face while deciding how you feel about the green.
5. Terracotta Without Orange Everywhere
The appeal of terracotta makeup is the warmth: cinnamon around the eyes, a soft warm cheek, a brick lip. But using the same strong orange on all three can be more than you bargained for.
Give the colors some variation. A brown shadow with a little warmth, a muted blush, and a rose-brown lipstick can sit together beautifully without matching exactly.
Put your favorite part on first
If you love your brick lipstick, start there. Then see how much blush you want with it. Your everyday shade may be enough, and you may decide to leave the eyes at mascara.
If copper eyeshadow is the part you’re excited about, do that first instead. A softer lip will let you see more of the eye color without adding another strong shade.
For less orange, try rose-brown. For more depth, look at richer cinnamon, sienna, or brick. The color should show against your skin without needing repeated layers.
You don’t need one multipurpose product to make this work. Separate eye, cheek, and lip products are fine; only use a product around the eyes if it’s labeled for that area.
These shades look lovely alongside chocolate, cream, olive, and denim. There are some easy clothing combinations in our brown suede jacket outfits, or you can use the 12-piece fall capsule wardrobe if you’re putting several outfits together.
6. Smudged Liner and a Soft Lip
This keeps the color closer to the lashes than the espresso look. Most of the lid stays clear, so it’s a useful option when you want definition without much eyeshadow.
Use a pencil that blends easily and work on one eye at a time. Draw a few short strokes along the upper lashes, then soften the top edge with a small brush before the pencil sets.
You can stop at the outer corner. No wing required.
Give yourself enough blending time
A long-wearing pencil isn’t always the easiest one to smudge. The NYX Professional Makeup Epic Wear Liner Stick in Deepest Brown is marketed as waterproof and smudge-resistant. If you use it here, work in small sections before it sets. A softer pencil may be easier if you prefer to take your time.
You can also press brown eyeshadow along the lashes with a small brush. That’s worth trying if your pencil keeps setting before you’ve finished blending.
Leave the lower lash line bare at first. If you want more definition there, add a little toward the outer corner and check before carrying it farther inward.
For the lips, choose a quiet shade on you: pink-brown, mauve, caramel, or a deeper brown. “Neutral” doesn’t have to mean pale beige.
7. A Red Lip With Your Everyday Makeup
A red lip with jeans and a plain top is such a good combination. You can keep the rest of your makeup familiar and still feel a little more dressed up.
Wear the base you like, whether that’s full coverage, concealer in a few places, or no foundation. Add your usual brows and mascara, then put on the red before deciding whether anything else is needed.
Think about how you’ll be wearing it
For a soft version, apply lightly and blot. For a defined lip, use a thin, even layer and tidy the outline with a lip brush. A coordinating liner can help if you enjoy a precise shape.
The Maybelline Color Sensational Lipstick in Red Revival is a red option to consider. If you already have one, try changing the amount before deciding the shade isn’t for you.
A little blush can help when the red looks disconnected from the rest of your face. You may need that more than extra eyeliner.
If you’re going out for dinner, take the lipstick with you. A defined red can need a touch-up after eating, and knowing that beforehand makes it a much less fussy choice.
Before You Add Another Layer
Put the brush down for a moment and look at your makeup with your hair down, your glasses on if you wear them, and the top you’re leaving the house in. A close-up mirror gives you very little sense of the whole look.
Check near a window, too. You may notice the blush is already quite visible or the brown shadow looks warmer than it did in the bathroom.
If something bothers you, change that part first. Blot an overly dark lip. Soften the edge of the shadow with a clean brush. Avoid adding more elsewhere just to make everything equally strong; that’s how a quick makeup look becomes much more makeup than you wanted.
Of course, if you like both the dark eye and the dark lip, keep them. These combinations are there to help you get dressed, not give you another set of rules.
A Few Fall Makeup Questions
Can I wear fall makeup without changing my everyday routine?
Yes. Try a berry lip with your usual mascara and blush, or use brown liner where you normally wear black. Keep the steps that already work for you. You can get a noticeably different look from one color change.
Which fall makeup colors work for cool undertones?
Taupe, cool cocoa, mauve, plum, and cranberry are useful starting points. If a shade looks gray or seems to disappear, try a deeper version rather than automatically switching to something warmer. How light or dark the color is matters alongside its undertone.
How do I wear these eyeshadow looks on hooded eyes?
Check your placement with your eyes open and brows relaxed. If the shadow disappears into the fold, blend a little above it where you can still see the color. Keep liner fairly narrow at first so it doesn’t cover all the visible lid space.
Do my blush and lipstick need to match?
No. A soft rose blush can look lovely with a deeper berry lip, for example. Apply the lipstick before deciding how much blush to add. It’s easier to judge them together than to finish the cheeks and discover they’re stronger than you wanted.
Start With the One You Want to Wear Tomorrow
Maybe that’s the berry lipstick you’ve been saving, worn lightly with your usual mascara. Or a little plum shadow instead of brown.
Try it with clothes you already enjoy wearing and see how it feels during your day. If you keep wanting to adjust it, change the amount or placement next time. If you like it as it is, there’s your fall makeup look.
Written for LoomAndLush — practical beauty ideas, wearable outfits, and seasonal styling.